Skip to content
  • +61 3 8644 7320
  • Email
  • Phone 7am to 12 Midnight - 7 days
  • Make a Booking
  • 中文
  • Locations
  • Contact
Search
Close this search box.
  • +61 3 8644 7320
  • Phone 7am to 12am - 7 days
  • 中文
Search
Close this search box.
  • 中文
Search
Close this search box.
  • +61 3 8644 7320
  • Phone 7am to Midnight - 7 days
Dribbin & Brown Criminal Lawyers
  • Legal Services
  • Our Lawyers
  • Criminal Defences
  • The System
  • Sentences
  • Blog
  • Locations
    • Ballarat
    • Broadmeadows
    • Dandenong
    • Frankston
    • Geelong
    • Melbourne CBD
    • Moorabbin
    • Ringwood
    • Werribee
  • Contact
Menu
  • Legal Services
  • Our Lawyers
  • Criminal Defences
  • The System
  • Sentences
  • Blog
  • Locations
    • Ballarat
    • Broadmeadows
    • Dandenong
    • Frankston
    • Geelong
    • Melbourne CBD
    • Moorabbin
    • Ringwood
    • Werribee
  • Contact

Duress

Contents of this page

Defence of Duress

Duress is a complete defence to all criminal offences. An act is committed under duress if it is committed due to an immediate threat of physical harm if the act is not done. This defence recognises that sometimes people commit offences to avoid threatened harm.

Duress operates to excuse a person that acts voluntarily and deliberately but under compulsion ( DPP v Parker [2016] VSCA 101).  A person must reasonably believe that a threat of harm has been made and will be carried out if an offence is not committed. The conduct must be a reasonable response to the threat and the only reasonable way the threatened harm can be avoided.

The defence is only available to the offence of murder if the accused ‘believes the threat is to inflict death or really serious injury.’ see Crimes Act 1958 s 322O(4)

In Victoria, s 3220 of the Crimes Act 1958 currently covers the defence of duress and applies to all offences committed on or after 1 November 2014. Prior to 2005, duress in Victoria was governed by the common law. The Crimes (Homicide) Act 2005 and the Crimes Amendment (Abolition of Defensive Homicide) Act 2014 introduced the new duress provisions into the Crimes Act 1958. Initially s 9AG of the Crimes Act 1958 was introduced, which was later repealed by s 3220 of the act. 

Statutory duress has replaced the common law defence of duress for all offences committed on or after 1 November 2014 ( see Crimes Act s 322Q). Common law duress however applies to all offences committed prior to 23 November 2005 and non- homicide cases committed prior to 1 November 2014.

To run the defence of duress is not easy. If you think the defence might apply to you, then do yourself a favour and call experienced criminal defence lawyers that have run, and won criminal cases based on this defence. 

Meaning of Duress

Duress is threats, violence, constraint, or other action used to coerce someone into doing something against their will or better judgement. To have acted under duress, the circumstances must have been such that the accused’s will was really and absolutely controlled, that s/he became a mere innocent instrument of the crime.

In Victoria, the defence is provided for under section 322O of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic):

  1. A person is not guilty of an offence in respect of conduct carried out by the person under duress.
  2. A person carries out conduct under duress if—
    1. the person reasonably believes that—
      1. subject to subsection (3), a threat of harm has been made that will be carried out unless an offence is committed; and
      2. carrying out the conduct is the only reasonable way that the threatened harm can be avoided; and
    2. the conduct is a reasonable response to the threat.
  3. A person does not carry out conduct under duress if the threat is made by or on behalf of a person with whom the person is voluntarily associating for the purpose of carrying out violent conduct.
  4. This section only applies in the case of murder if the person believes that the threat is to inflict death or really serious injury.

Evidence Required to Establish the Defence

There is an evidentiary burden on an accused to raise the defence. When duress is raised, it is up to the prosecution to prove that the act did not occur under duress. The prosecution must eliminate any reasonable possibility that the accused acted under duress – see s 322I(1) Crimes Act 1958.

To prove the accused did not act under duress, the prosecution must disprove one or more of the following elements:

  • The accused reasonably believes that a threat of harm has been made;
  • The accused reasonably believes that the threat will be carried out unless an offence is committed;
  • The accused reasonable believes that carrying out the conduct is the only reasonable way the threatened harm can be avoided;
  • The conduct is a reasonable response to the threat;
  • The threat was not made by or on behalf of a person with whom the accused is voluntary associating for the purpose of carrying out violent conduct.

The test is whether, on the version of evidence most favourable to the accused, a jury, acting reasonably, could fail to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused was not acting under duress: Taiapa v The Queen [2009].

Duress and Family Violence

Evidence of family violence can be raised by the defence to establish that an offence was committed under duress – see 322P of the Crimes Act 1958.

Our Legal Services

Appeals

Assault Offences

Asset Confiscation

Bail Application

Breach Offences

Centrelink Fraud

Children’s Court

Computer Offences

Council Charges

Drink Driving

Driving Offences

Drug Offences

Family Violence

Firearm Offences

Fraud Offences

Infringement Warrants

Intervention Orders

Murder Trials

Perjury Charges

Pervert the Course of Justice

Royal Commission

RSPCA Offences

Sex Offences

Theft

Traffic Offences

Violence

Weapons

White Collar Crime

Latest Case Studies

Breach Intervention Order Ringwood

Breach of Sex Offenders Registration Obligations Melbourne

CCO Result for Drug Trafficking Victoria

Cultivate Cannabis Charges

Diversion For Careless Driving

Diversion For Family Violence

Diversion For Stalking and Trespass

Diversion For Unlawful Assault

Intentionally Cause Injury Dandenong

Personal Safety Application Victoria

Recklessly Causing Injury – Dandenong

Section 123 of the Family Violence Protection Act 2008

Sexual Assault Charges Victoria

Threat to Kill; Intentionally Causing Injury

Trafficking Drug of Dependence Ecstasy

  • Law Institute Accredited Specialist Criminal Lawyers
  • Legal Aid enquiries welcome
  • Over 100 years firm experience practising as traffic lawyers and criminal defence lawyers
specialist criminal solicitor warning
Do not ask any firm to act on your behalf in relation to a criminal or traffic law offence unless they specialise in criminal or traffic law.
  • Law Institute Accredited Specialist Criminal Lawyers
  • Legal Aid enquiries welcome
  • Over 100 years firm experience practising as traffic lawyers and criminal defence lawyers
specialist criminal solicitor warning
Do not ask any firm to act on your behalf in relation to a criminal or traffic law offence unless they specialise in criminal or traffic law.

What Our Clients Say

Ross M
Dear Dave, Just a follow up thanks for your professional service & presentation yesterday – very happy with the outcome and the comments from the Magistrate. Thanks again, and...
Maria
Many thanks for the wonderful support I received from David Dribbin as he represented me in court today. It was an extremely emotional experience for me and without judgement...
Adrian W
A big thank you Dave. You made it seamless. You are a quality egg and hopefully I'll see you again under different circumstances. All the best!
Michael S
Dear Rebeca, Thank you again for your support and guidance over the past six months, it is my belief that Dribbin and Brown went far beyond there charter when...
Russell P
Dear David and Team I would like to “Thank You” for a job well done. The result, from the trial was truly amazing. I very much appreciated your courtesy, professionalism...
Grant B
I phoned Michael Brown of Dribbin and Brown after total disappointment in another criminal lawyer firm... In my situation that required communication, information and a great deal of understanding,...
Sam B
Thank you for your outstanding service.... A great result for us...
Yvonne and Peter Braithwaite
Thanks for your excellent work for Yvonne last Friday. Your courtesy, empathy and professionalism was greatly appreciated. All the best for the future.
Helen and Lingbo Yang
Thank you for your support and help of Lingbo’s case for these days and everything is going smoothly. The outcome is better than we expected because of your rich...
…
Mike! Jacqui was great! Re my drive whist suspended charge, I held my license with a small fine to be payed in 4 months! Can't thank you enough! Thanks for...
Haley M
We cannot thank you enough, it still doesn't feel real to us yet as it has caused a lot of strain and stress over a very long period of...

Need help? Call our 7am to Midnight Phone Service on +61 03 8644 7320

Dribbin & Brown Criminal Solicitors Melbourne

Facebook-f Twitter

© 2023 Dribbin & Brown

Melbourne – 03 8644 7320
13/200 Queen St
Melbourne Vic 3000

Frankston – 03 8644 7322
8/395-399 Nepean Hwy
Frankston VIC, 3199

Ballarat – 03 8644 7310
Eureka House
11 Lydiard Street South
Ballarat VIC, 3350

Dandenong – 03 8644 7315
1a/147 Foster St
Dandenong, VIC, 3175

Moorabbin – 03 8644 7328
Level 1, 441 South Rd
Moorabbin, Vic, 3189

Geelong – 03 8644 7300
2/13 Fenwick Street
Geelong Vic 3220

Ringwood – 03 8644 7325
7/2 Nelson St
Ringwood VIC 3134

Werribee – 03 9116 9595
9/7 Bridge Street
Werribee VIC 3030

Broadmeadows – 03 9116 9500
StartNorth at Townhall
12 Dimboola Rd
Broadmeadows VIC 3047

Dribbin & Brown

  • About Us
  • What We Do
  • The System
  • Criminal Defences
  • Sentences
  • Criminal Lawyers Blog
  • Client Testimonials
  • Sitemap

Melbourne – 03 8644 7320
13/200 Queen St
Melbourne Vic 3000

Frankston – 03 8644 7322
8/395-399 Nepean Hwy
Frankston VIC, 3199

Ballarat – 03 8644 7310
Eureka House
11 Lydiard Street South
Ballarat VIC, 3350

Ringwood – 03 8644 7325
7/2 Nelson St
Ringwood VIC 3134

Dandenong – 03 8644 7315
1a/147 Foster St
Dandenong, VIC, 3175

Moorabbin – 03 8644 7328
Level 1, 441 South Rd
Moorabbin, Vic, 3189

Geelong – 03 8644 7300
2/13 Fenwick Street
Geelong Vic 3220

Broadmeadows – (03) 9116 9500
StartNorth at Townhall
12 Dimboola Rd
Broadmeadows VIC 3047

Werribee – 03 9116 9595
9/7 Bridge Street
Werribee VIC 3030

© 2023 Dribbin & Brown

Facebook-f Twitter

Dribbin & Brown

  • About Us
  • What We Do
  • The System
  • Criminal Defences
  • Sentences
  • Criminal Lawyers Blog
  • Client Testimonials

7am to Midnight Phone Service: +61 03 8644 7320  Contact Us | Book An Appointment

Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Traffic Lawyers Melbourne

7am to 12am Phone Service: +61 03 8644 7320
Contact Us | Book An Appointment
Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Traffic Lawyers Melbourne