Skip to content
  • +61 3 8644 7320
  • Email
  • Phone 7am to 12 Midnight - 7 days
  • Make a Booking
  • 中文
  • Locations
  • Contact
Search
Close
  • +61 3 8644 7320
  • Phone 7am to 12am - 7 days
  • 中文
Search
Close
  • 中文
Search
Close
  • +61 3 8644 7320
  • Phone 7am to Midnight - 7 days

Phone Appointments and Video Conferences Available

IMPORTANT COVID-19 COURT NEWS UPDATE

Dribbin & Brown Criminal Lawyers
  • Legal Services
  • Our Lawyers
  • Criminal Defences
  • The System
  • Sentences
  • Blog
  • Locations
  • Contact
Menu
  • Legal Services
  • Our Lawyers
  • Criminal Defences
  • The System
  • Sentences
  • Blog
  • Locations
  • Contact

s197 Arson

Are you Facing Arson Charges?

Dribbin & Brown Criminal Lawyers have handled hundred’s of arson cases, if you have been charged, then we can help you.

What is Arson?

Arson is an offence relating to the destruction or damage of property by fire.

Section 197(6) of the Crimes Act 1958 captures both

  • Intentional damage (e.g., setting someone’s property alight with the goal of damaging it); and
  • Careless damage (e.g., lighting a fire knowing or believing it is likely to damage the property);

Arson also extends to circumstances where the fire damage was caused either to endanger the life of another, or to dishonestly achieve a gain of some kind. As such, it is clear that arson is a serious offence, carrying a likely term of imprisonment if found guilty.

What are the Elements of Arson?

Section 197(6) of the Crimes Act 1958 outlines the offence of arson as the use of fire in the destruction or damage of property. In all cases, the prosecution is required to establish that the defendant destroyed or damaged the property in question by the use of fire, and that they intended, or knew or believed it was more likely than not, that by using fire they would damage or destroy the property.

The prosecution is then required to prove one of the following additional sets of elements in establishing the charge of arson:

Arson from Criminal Damage (section 197(1)):

  • The property damaged or destroyed belonged to another; and
  • The defendant had no lawful excuse for their conduct.

Arson from Criminal Damage Intending to Endanger Life (section 197(2)):

  • The defendant intended, or knew or believed it was more likely than not, that the destruction or damage to property by fire would endanger the life of another; and
  • The defendant had no lawful excuse for their conduct.

Arson from Criminal Damage with a View to Gain (section 197(3)):

  • The defendant’s intention, or knowledge or belief of it being more likely than not, that they would cause property damage or destruction by fire was dishonest; and
  • The defendant completed their conduct with the view to gain for themselves or another.

Property, Damage, and Ownership

For the purposes of this offence, any property damaged or destroyed is any real or tangible property (e.g., buildings, vehicles, etc.). The Crimes Act 1958 does not require the prosecution to establish specific ownership of the property, or even sole ownership, simply that it is owned by someone, relating to whether some form of custody or right is held over the property by a legal entity (e.g., a person, trust (section 196(3)), or corporation (section 196(4)).

Regarding damage or destruction:

  • Destruction requires the property be rendered useless for its intended purpose;
  • Damage involves permanently or temporarily affecting the physical integrity of the property – merely interfering with its use or operation its not sufficient (Grajewski v DPP [2019] HCA 8, [13]).

In the case of arson, the expected damage or destruction would be that caused by fire – burns in surfaces, structural damage, etc.

Intention, Knowledge, and Belief

Any requirement of intention, knowledge, or belief pertaining to either the damage or destruction of property, or the endangering of the life of another, requires the specific intent, knowledge, or belief to do so by the use of fire (R v Cooper (G) and Cooper (Y) [1991] CLR 524).

Section 197(4)(b) and 197(5)(b) of the Crimes Act 1958 extends the defendant’s intent to include their knowledge or belief that it was more likely than not that the damage/destruction or life endangerment would result by their use of fire. In proving this, the prosecution need only prove that the defendant knew or believed it was more than 50% likely; this is comparable to similar tests for recklessness, which simply require a consequence be probable.

Specifically relating to where the offence of arson endangers the life of another, it is worth highlighting that the intent, knowledge, or belief referred to in the Crimes Act 1958 relate to the danger caused by the damage or destruction of property, not the danger caused by the fire itself (R v Steer [1988] AC 111).

Dishonesty and Gain

The requirement of dishonesty under section 197(3) of the Crimes Act 1958 requires the prosecution to prove that the intent, knowledge, or belief of the defendant as to the damage or destruction caused were both capable of and did in fact make their conduct dishonest (Macleod v R (2003) 214 CLR 230). Dishonesty adopts is regular meaning here, but is assessed against an ordinary person.

Any view to gain derived from this dishonesty need not relate only to the defendant themselves, but can refer to another. Additionally, ‘gain’ in the context of this section would seem to adopt its ordinary meaning, and is not limited to monetary gain. However, the view to gain must have existed when the act of the defendant occurred.

What is the Maximum/Average Penalty?

Section 197(7) of the Crimes Act 1958 outlines a maximum penalty of 15 years imprisonment if found guilty of arson.

Regarding the average sentence handed down, it is important to note that the sentence of any given matter is entirely related to the circumstances of that case.  Any averages provided are intended to only be a guide; if you wish for a more detailed assessment of your likely sentence, please call the office to arrange a consultation.

With this in mind, the Sentencing Councill of Victoria found that, over the past five years from 2015-2016 to 2019-2020, the average length of imprisonment for cases of arson was 2 years and 4 months.

What Defences are Available?

There are two sets of defences which may be relevant, depending on the base offence (section 197(1), (2), or (3) of the Crimes Act 1958) being proved by the prosecution:

Lawful Excuse -> Statutory Defences (section 197(1) and (2) of the Crimes Act 1958):

Right or Authority to Destroy or Damage (section 201(2)(a) of the Crimes Act 1958):

  • The defendant must have honestly believed that:
    • The property solely belonged to them; or
    • They had some right or interest in the property that permitted them to cause the destruction or damage by fire; or
    • They had, or would have, received consent from all necessary parties who could consent to the destruction or damage.
  • Protection of Property, Interest, or Right (section 201(2)(b) of the Crimes Act 1958):
    • The defendant must have acted to protect property either belonging to themselves or another, or to protect a right or interest in property that was, or they believed to be, vested in themselves or another.
    • The defendant must have honestly believed the property, right, or interest was in immediate danger, and that the conduct taken to protect property was reasonable given the circumstances.

Common Law Defences (all instances):

Self-Defence:

  • The defendant reasonably believed that causing the damage or destruction of property by fire were necessary to defend themselves.

Consent:

  • The defendant had consent from all owners of the property to cause the damage, destruction, or life endangerment.

Note this is a non-exhaustive list of defences that may be relevant in cases of arson. For other defences, see our criminal law defences page.

Where Will my Case be Heard?

A charge of arson, depending on the damage caused, will typically be heard in the Magistrates Court, unless the value of property damage exceeds $100,000. In such instances, the charge may be heard in the County Court.

What Should I Do Next?

Arson is a serious charge which can result in lengthy imprisonment if you are convicted. You should make an appointment with an arson lawyer as soon as possible to ensure proper representation and the best possible defence is provided for you.)

Assault Charges

Summary Offences Act

s9 Wilful Damage

s23 Common Assault

s52A Offence to Harass Witnesses etc.

Crimes Act 1958

Affray

s15A Intentionally Causing Serious Injury in Circumstances of Gross Violence

s16 Intentionally Causing Serious Injury

s17 Recklessly Causing Serious Injury

s18 Intentionally Causing Injury

s18 Recklessly Causing Injury

s19 Offence to Administer Certain Substances

s20 Threats to Kill

s21A Stalking

s24 Negligently Causing Serious Injury

s27 Extortion With Threats to Kill

s28 Extortion With Threat to Destroy Property

s30 Threatening Injury to Prevent Arrest

s31A Use of Firearms in the Commission of an Offence

s31B Being Armed with Criminal Intent

s63A Kidnapping

s75 Robbery

s75A Armed Robbery

s77 Aggravated Burglary – Assault

s197 Arson

s197 Criminal Damage

Common Law

Common Law Assault (Per the Common Law)

False Imprisonment

Public Nuisance

Riot

Rout

Unlawful Assembly

Repealed Legislation

s19A Intentionally Causing a Very Serious Disease (Repealed 2015)

Case Studies

Arson Charges Case study

Assault and Breach Intervention Order Charges, Not Guilty.

Assault Offences County Court

Assault on Taxi Driver

Assault; Criminal Damage

Assaults

Attempted Robbery

Conduct Endanger Life – Withdrawn

Conduct Endangering Life

Criminal Damage Charges Geelong

Damage Property Case Study Geelong

Diversion For Unlawful Assault

Intentionally Cause Injury Dandenong

Recklessly Causing Injury – Dandenong

Recklessly Causing Injury & Assault Case Study (Withdrawn)

Resist Arrest; Breach Suspended Sentence

Section 123 of the Family Violence Protection Act 2008

Sexual Assault Charges – Section 40(1) of the Crimes Act

Threat to Kill

Threat to Kill; Intentionally Causing Injury

Unlawful Assault & Recklessly Causing Injury

Unlawful Assault Charges Frankston

Our Legal Services

Appeals

Assault Offences

Asset Confiscation

Bail Application

Breach Offences

Centrelink Fraud

Children’s Court

Computer Offences

Council Charges

Drink Driving

Driving Offences

Drug Offences

Family Violence

Firearm Offences

Fraud Offences

Infringement Warrants

Intervention Orders

Murder Trials

Perjury Charges

Pervert the Course of Justice

Royal Commission

RSPCA Offences

Sex Offences

Theft

Traffic Offences

Violence

Weapons

White Collar Crime

  • Law Institute Accredited Specialist Criminal Lawyers
  • Legal Aid enquiries welcome
  • Over 100 years firm experience practising as traffic lawyers and criminal defence lawyers
specialist criminal solicitor warning
Do not ask any firm to act on your behalf in relation to a criminal or traffic law offence unless they specialise in criminal or traffic law.
  • Law Institute Accredited Specialist Criminal Lawyers
  • Legal Aid enquiries welcome
  • Over 100 years firm experience practising as traffic lawyers and criminal defence lawyers
specialist criminal solicitor warning
Do not ask any firm to act on your behalf in relation to a criminal or traffic law offence unless they specialise in criminal or traffic law.

What Our Clients Say

Helen and Lingbo Yang
Thank you for your support and help of Lingbo’s case for these days and everything is going smoothly. The outcome is better than we expected because of your rich...
…
Mike! Jacqui was great! Re my drive whist suspended charge, I held my license with a small fine to be payed in 4 months! Can't thank you enough! Thanks for...
Michael S
Dear Rebeca, Thank you again for your support and guidance over the past six months, it is my belief that Dribbin and Brown went far beyond there charter when...
Sam B
Thank you for your outstanding service.... A great result for us...
Ross M
Dear Dave, Just a follow up thanks for your professional service & presentation yesterday – very happy with the outcome and the comments from the Magistrate. Thanks again, and...
Maria
Many thanks for the wonderful support I received from David Dribbin as he represented me in court today. It was an extremely emotional experience for me and without judgement...
Haley M
We cannot thank you enough, it still doesn't feel real to us yet as it has caused a lot of strain and stress over a very long period of...
Yvonne and Peter Braithwaite
Thanks for your excellent work for Yvonne last Friday. Your courtesy, empathy and professionalism was greatly appreciated. All the best for the future.
Grant B
I phoned Michael Brown of Dribbin and Brown after total disappointment in another criminal lawyer firm... In my situation that required communication, information and a great deal of understanding,...
Russell P
Dear David and Team I would like to “Thank You” for a job well done. The result, from the trial was truly amazing. I very much appreciated your courtesy, professionalism...
Adrian W
A big thank you Dave. You made it seamless. You are a quality egg and hopefully I'll see you again under different circumstances. All the best!

Need help? Call our 7am to Midnight Phone Service on +61 (03) 8644 7320

Dribbin & Brown Criminal Solicitors Melbourne

Facebook-f Twitter

© 2021 Dribbin & Brown

Melbourne – 03 8644 7320
13/200 Queen St
Melbourne Vic 3000

Frankston – 03 8644 7322
8/395-399 Nepean Hwy
Frankston VIC, 3199

Ballarat – 03 8644 7310
Armstrong House
17 Armstrong Street South
Ballarat Central VIC, 3350

Dandenong – 03 8644 7315
1a/147 Foster St
Dandenong, VIC, 3175

Moorabbin – 03 8644 7328
Level 1, 441 South Rd
Moorabbin, Vic, 3189

Geelong – 03 8644 7300
2/13 Fenwick Street
Geelong Vic 3220

Ringwood – 03 8644 7325
7/2 Nelson St
Ringwood VIC 3134

Werribee – (03) 9116 9595
9/7 Bridge Street
Werribee VIC 3030

Dribbin & Brown

  • About Us
  • What We Do
  • The System
  • Criminal Defences
  • Sentences
  • Criminal Lawyers Blog
  • Client Testimonials

Melbourne – 03 8644 7320
13/200 Queen St
Melbourne Vic 3000

Frankston – 03 8644 7322
8/395-399 Nepean Hwy
Frankston VIC, 3199

Ballarat – 03 8644 7310
Armstrong House
17 Armstrong Street South
Ballarat Central VIC, 3350

Dandenong – 03 8644 7315
1a/147 Foster St
Dandenong, VIC, 3175

Moorabbin – 03 8644 7328
Level 1, 441 South Rd
Moorabbin, Vic, 3189

Geelong – 03 8644 7300
2/13 Fenwick Street
Geelong Vic 3220

Ringwood – 03 8644 7325
7/2 Nelson St
Ringwood VIC 3134

Werribee – (03) 9116 9595
9/7 Bridge Street
Werribee VIC 3030

© 2021 Dribbin & Brown

Facebook-f Twitter

Dribbin & Brown

  • About Us
  • What We Do
  • The System
  • Criminal Defences
  • Sentences
  • Criminal Lawyers Blog
  • Client Testimonials

7am to Midnight Phone Service: +61 (03) 8644 7320  Contact Us | Book An Appointment

Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Traffic Lawyers Melbourne

7am to 12am Phone Service: +61 (03) 8644 7320
Contact Us | Book An Appointment
Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Traffic Lawyers Melbourne