Dribbin & Brown is committed to helping you. We are available from 7AM-12AM Monday To Sunday. Call us for a Free Consultation
CONTACT US
  • Legal Services
    • appeal
      Appeals
      county-court
      Appeals to the County Court
      legal-aid-lawyers-icon.svg
      Error of law appeals
      victorial-court
      Appeal to the Court of Appeal
      rehearing
      Apply for Rehearing
      rspca-offences
      Dog Offences
      rspca-offences
      Animal Cruelty (RSPCA)
      rspca-offences
      Animal Control Orders
      assault-charges-icon.svg
      Assault Offences
      family-violence
      Family Violence
      manslaughter
      Manslaughter
      murder-trials
      Murder
      self-defense-icon
      Self Defence
      bail-application
      Bail Application Lawyers
      we-care.svg
      What is Bail
      county-supreme-court-procedure
      Bail Procedure
      intervention-orders-icon.svg
      Unacceptable Risk
      we-are-accredited.svg
      Show Compelling Reasons
      bail-application
      Exceptional Circumstances
      supreme-court
      Supreme Court Bail
      bail-application
      Breaching Bail
      we-care.svg
      Breaching a Bond
      county-supreme-court-procedure
      Breaching a CCO
      intervention-orders-icon.svg
      Breaching an IVO
      we-are-accredited.svg
      Breaching SORA
      firearm-offences
      Firearms
      weapons
      Weapons
      assets-consfication
      Asset Confiscation
      centrelink-fraud
      Centrelink fraud
      fraud-offences
      Fraud
      perjury-charges
      Pejury
      pervert-the-course-of-justice
      Pervert the Course of Justice
      theft
      Theft
      white-collar-crime
      White Collar Crime
      drink-driving-icon.svg
      Drink Driving
      drug-lawyers-icon.svg
      Drug Driving
      driving-offences
      Driving Offences (General)
      traffic-offences
      Traffic Offences
      infringement-warrants
      Infringement Warrants
      county-supreme-court-procedure
      Honest and Reasonable Mistake
      white-collar-crime
      Personal Safety Intervention Orders (PSIO)
      family-violence
      Family Violence Intervention Orders (FVIO)
      magistrates-court
      How to get an IVO
      victorial-court
      What can happen at Court?
      infringement-warrants
      Should I accept an IVO?
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Sex Offender Registration Exemption
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Failing to comply with Sex Offence Registration
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      What is digital penetration
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Rape
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Sexual Assault
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Indecent Assault
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Consent
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      All Sexual Offences
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Meaning of Consent
      childrens-court
      Children’s Court
      computer-offences
      Cyber Crime
      drug-lawyers-icon.svg
      Drug Offences
      appeal
      Food Prosecution
      infringement-warrants
      Infringement Warrants
      royal-commisison
      Royal Commission
      rspca-offences
      Animal Cruelty
      appeal
      Appeal
      assault-charges-icon.svg
      Assault Offences
      assets-consfication
      Asset Confiscation
      bail-application
      Bail Applications
      breach-offences
      Breach Offences
      centrelink-fraud
      Centrelink Fraud
      childrens-court
      Childrens Court Charges
      computer-offences
      Computer Offences
      rspca-offences
      Dog Offences
      drink-driving-icon.svg
      Drink Driving
      drink-driving-icon.svg
      Driving Offences
      drug-lawyers-icon.svg
      Drug Driving
      drug-lawyers-icon.svg
      Drug Offences
      family-violence
      Family Violence
      firearm-offences
      Firearm Offences
      appeal
      Food Prosecutions
      fraud-offences
      Fraud
      infringement-warrants
      Infringment Warrants
      intervention-orders-icon.svg
      Intervention Orders
      manslaughter
      Manslaughter
      murder-trials
      Murder Trials
      perjury-charges
      Perjury
      pervert-the-course-of-justice
      Pervert The Course Of Justice
      royal-commisison
      Royal Commision
      sexual-assualt-icon.svg
      Sex Offences
      theft
      Theft
      traffic-offences
      Traffic Offences
      weapons
      Weapons
      white-collar-crime
      White Collar Crime
  • Our Lawyers
  • Criminal Defences
  • Case Studies
  • The System
  • Sentences
    • How to Avoid a Criminal Record?
    • Conviction and Non-Conviction
    • Spent Convictions Victoria
    • What is Diversion?
    • Apply for a Rehearing
    • Pleading Not Guilty in the Magistrates’ Court
    • What shows up on a police check?
    • Appeals
    • What happens to my fingerprints?
  • Locations
    • Melbourne
    • Frankston
    • Dandenong
    • Ringwood
    • Moorabbin
    • Geelong
    • Ballarat
    • Werribee
    • Broadmeadows
  • Contact
  • (03) 8644 7333
  • Legal Services
    • Appeals
      • Appeals
      • Appeals to the County Court
      • Error of law appeals
      • Appeal to the Court of Appeal
      • Apply for Rehearing
    • Animal Offences
      • Dog Offences
      • Animal Cruelty (RSPCA)
      • Animal Control Orders
    • Assault
      • Assault Offences
      • Family Violence
      • Manslaughter
      • Murder
      • Self Defence
    • Bail
      • Bail Application Lawyers
      • What is Bail
      • Bail Procedure
      • Unacceptable Risk
      • Show Compelling Reasons
      • Exceptional Circumstances
      • Supreme Court Bail
    • Breaching Court Orders
      • Breaching Bail
      • Breaching a Bond
      • Breaching a CCO
      • Breaching an IVO
      • Breaching SORA
    • Firearms & Weapons
      • Firearms
      • Weapons
    • Dishonesty & Property Offences
      • Asset Confiscation
      • Centrelink fraud
      • Fraud
      • Pejury
      • Pervert the Course of Justice
      • Theft
      • White Collar Crime
    • Driving Offences
      • Drink Driving
      • Drug Driving
      • Driving Offences (General)
      • Traffic Offences
      • Infringement Warrants
      • Honest and Reasonable Mistake
    • Intervention Orders
      • Personal Safety Intervention Orders (PSIO)
      • Family Violence Intervention Orders (FVIO)
      • How to get an IVO
      • What can happen at Court?
      • Should I accept an IVO?
    • Sex Offences
      • Sex Offender Registration Exemption
      • Failing to comply with Sex Offence Registration
      • What is digital penetration
      • Rape
      • Sexual Assault
      • Indecent Assault
      • Consent
      • All Sexual Offences
    • Other Offences
      • Children’s Court
      • Cyber Crime
      • Drug Offences
      • Food Prosecution
      • Infringement Warrants
      • Royal Commission
    • All
  • Our Lawyers
  • Criminal Defences
  • Case Studies
  • The System
  • Sentences
    • How to Avoid a Criminal Record?
    • Conviction and Non-Conviction
    • Spent Convictions Victoria
    • What is Diversion?
    • Rehearing
    • Apply for a Rehearing
    • Pleading Not Guilty in the Magistrates’ Court
    • Appeals
    • What shows up on a police check?
    • What happens to my fingerprints?
  • Blog
  • Locations
  • Contact

Appeals

Appeal Error of Law From Magistrates’ Court

Home > Offence > Appeal > Appeal Error of Law From Magistrates’ Court

Article Content

Appeal to the Supreme Court on a Question of Law

Under section 272(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic) (the CPA), a party involved in a criminal proceeding, except a committal proceeding, in the Magistrates’ Court has the right to appeal to the Supreme Court.

This appeal can only be made on a question of law (i.e. a legal issue, not a factual issue) from a final order made by the Magistrates’ Court. If a decision is appealed to the Supreme Court on a question of law, no appeal may be entered at the County Court (s273 of the CPA).

If you are considering an appeal to the Supreme Court on a question of law, it is critical to consider whether it may be preferable to appeal to the County Court against your sentence or conviction in the first instance. It is very important to speak to an experienced criminal lawyer before appealing to the Supreme Court on an error of law.

Determining whether an appeal to the Supreme Court on an error of law is appropriate usually involves consideration of the following matters:

  1. Did the court apply the correct legal test?
  2. Was there any evidence to support a finding of fact made?
  3. Did the facts found fall within the statute properly construed?

In relation to the second proposition, the issue of whether there was any evidence to support a finding of fact depends on whether there was evidence that a Magistrate, as a reasonable person, could rely upon to reach the conclusion. Specifically, the question is whether the finding was open to the Magistrate under the law. It is not sufficient to argue that the decision was against the weight of the evidence. That is, the appellant must show that the Magistrate:

  • took an irrelevant factor into account;
  • failed to take into account a relevant factor;
  • erred in the use of discretion; or
  • improperly applied the law to the facts.

Case Study: Error of law example

One example of a Magistrate improperly excluding evidence amounting to an error of law is in Engebretson v Bartlett. In that case, the accused was convicted and sentenced to imprisonment for recklessly causing serious injury.

The accused relied on the defence of self-defence in relation to the offending conduct. However, the Magistrate excluded important evidence that the accused intended to lead from a witness that painted a different picture of the circumstances leading to the alleged offending and how the fight started.

The question for the Court on appeal was, did the Magistrate err in ruling that the evidence was inadmissible? The relevant finding by the Supreme Court, in that case, was that the Magistrate did make an error of law, and the matter was remitted to the Magistrates’ Court before a different Magistrate for redetermination.

Seeking leave to appeal on a question of law

Appeals to the Supreme Court on a question of law involve several complex procedures and strict deadlines:

  • Notices of appeal must be filed within 28 days of the lower court’s final order.
  • If filed later, they are considered appeals outside the normal time frame and require leave to proceed. 
  • A number of matters must be addressed in the notice of appeal.
  • The other party must be formally notified and served with the appeal notice.
  • Affidavits must be filed with the appropriate exhibits attached.

Appeals are a complex and specialised area of law that requires the expertise of a specialist lawyer.

After hearing and determining the appeal

If the Supreme Court is satisfied that an error in law was made, the Court may:

  • Remit the matter to the Magistrates’ Court (have it returned to the original court for a rehearing).
  • Deal with the matter itself, depending on the state of the evidence and whether it is in the interests of justice.
  • Dismiss the appeal if the Court is satisfied that the accused did not lose the chance of acquittal that was open. In doing so, the Court may undertake its own evaluation of evidence and take into account the natural limitations involved in such a review.

If you feel that an injustice has occurred in Court and you would like advice on the prospects of an appeal in your case, please contact our office so we can further investigate your concerns.

As this article hopefully demonstrates, this is an extremely technical area of the law that requires an appeal lawyer’s assistance.

Contact Us
Not Sure Where to Start?

Related Information

  • How to Avoid a Criminal Record?
  • Conviction and Non-Conviction
  • Spent Convictions Victoria
  • What is Diversion?
  • Plead Not Guilty
  • Apply for a Rehearing
  • Appeals
  • What shows up on a police check?
  • How to Avoid a Criminal Record?
  • Conviction and Non-Conviction
  • Spent Convictions Victoria
  • What is Diversion?
  • Plead Not Guilty
  • Apply for a Rehearing
  • Appeals
  • What shows up on a police check?

Appeals

Appeals to the County Court

Appeal Error of Law From Magistrates’ Court

Appeals to the Court of Appeal

Appeals to the High Court of Australia

Case Studies

Driving Suspended | Breach Interlock | Appeal to County Court

Application for Rehearing | Driving Charges | No Licence Loss

Appeal Outside of Time | Magistrates Court to County Court

Drug Trafficking | Appeal Against Sentence | County Court

Serious Driving Charges | Appeal to County Court | Avoided Gaol

Drug Trafficking | Gaol | Successful Sentence Appeal

Our Full Legal Services We Can Assist You With

‹
  • All
  • Assault
  • Bail
  • Dishonesty
  • Dog Offences
  • Driving
  • Sex
  • Drugs
  • Public Order
  • Other
›
Animal Cruelty
arrow
Appeal
arrow
Assault Offences
arrow
Asset Confiscation
arrow
Bail Applications
arrow
Breach Offences
arrow
Centrelink Fraud
arrow
Childrens Court Charges
arrow
Computer Offences
arrow
Dog Offences
arrow
Drink Driving
arrow
Driving Offences
arrow
Drug Driving
arrow
Drug Offences
arrow
Family Violence
arrow
Firearm Offences
arrow
Food Prosecutions
arrow
Fraud
arrow
Infringement Warrants
arrow
Intervention Orders
arrow
Manslaughter
arrow
Murder Trials
arrow
Perjury
arrow
Pervert the Course of Justice
arrow
Royal Commission
arrow
Sex Offences
arrow
Theft
arrow
Traffic Offences
arrow
Weapons
arrow
White Collar Crime
arrow
Animal Cruelty
arrow
Breach Offences
arrow
Firearm Offences
arrow
Infringement Warrants
arrow
Intervention Orders
arrow
Murder Trials
arrow
Weapons
arrow
Appeal
arrow
Assault Offences
arrow
Family Violence
arrow
Manslaughter
arrow
Asset Confiscation
arrow
Centrelink Fraud
arrow
Computer Offences
arrow
Fraud
arrow
Perjury
arrow
Pervert the Course of Justice
arrow
Theft
arrow
White Collar Crime
arrow
Bail Applications
arrow
Childrens Court Charges
arrow
Food Prosecutions
arrow
Royal Commission
arrow
Dog Offences
arrow
Drink Driving
arrow
Driving Offences
arrow
Drug Driving
arrow
Traffic Offences
arrow
Drug Offences
arrow
Sex Offences
arrow
Latest Case Studies

Learn about our latest wins

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Etiam eu turpis magna, dictum est a, mattis tellus. Sed dignissim, metus nec fringilla accumsan, risus sem sollicitudin lacus.

See All Case Studies

Common Assault of a Child | Diversion | No Conviction

Samantha Barwick

Dandenong Magistrates Court

Driving on Wrong Side of Road | Charge Withdrawn | Ballarat

Benjamin Smith

Ballarat Magistrates Court

Drug Driving | Careless Driving | Bond | No Conviction

Jess Wensley

Geelong Magistrates Court

Theft | Obtain Financial Advantage by Deception | Diversion | No Record

Jess Wensley

Geelong Magistrates Court

Reckless Conduct | Careless Drive | Fine | No Conviction

Benjamin Smith

Ballarat Magistrates Court

PSIO | Cross Applications | Struck Out | Melbourne

Jaime Du Cane

Melbourne Magistrates Court

Choose a Firm That Specialises in Criminal or Traffic Law for the Best Support With Your Case.

Need Help? Call our team 7am – 12 midnight (7 days a week)

Get In Touch
Talk To A Specialist
  • Law Institute Accredited Specialist Criminal Lawyers
  • Legal Aid enquiries welcome
  • 24/7 Availability
  • 7am - Midnight
  • (03) 8644 7333
  • Email Address
  • Book An Appointment

Helpful Links

  • About Us
  • Blog
  • What We Do
  • The System
  • Criminal Defences
  • Sentences
  • Criminal Lawyers Blog
  • Case Studies

Criminal Services

  • Bail Application
  • Domestic Violence Defence
  • Drink Driving Defence
  • Careless Driving Defence
  • Sexual Assault Defence
  • Speeding Fines Appeal

Office Locations

Melbourne
  • (03) 8644 7320
  • 4/271 William St

    Melbourne Vic 3000
Frankston
  • (03) 8644 7322
  • 8/395-399 Nepean Hwy

    Frankston VIC, 3199
Ballarat
  • (03) 8644 7310
  • Eureka House
11, Lydiard Street South Ballarat VIC, 3350
Dandenong 
  • (03) 8644 7315
  • 1a/147 Foster
    St
Dandenong, VIC, 3175
Moorabbin
  • (03) 8644 7328
  • Level 1, 441 South Rd
    
Moorabbin, Vic, 3189
Geelong 
  • (03) 8644 7300
  • 2/13 Fenwick Street
    
Geelong Vic 3220
Ringwood 
  • (03) 8644 7325
  • 7/2 Nelson St
Ringwood VIC 3134
Werribee
  • (03) 9116 9595
  • 9/7 Bridge Street
Werribee VIC 3030
Broadmeadows
  • (03) 9116 9500
  • StartNorth at Townhall12 Dimboola Rd
Broadmeadows VIC 3047

© Copyright 2025 Dribbin & Brown Criminal Law | Contact Us | Privacy | Disclaimer

Find Location Find Location Make Appointment Make Appointment

Search